Medicare Open Enrollment runs October 15 through December 7 every year — and scam calls follow the calendar. Fraudsters know beneficiaries are actively comparing plans, and they time their calls to blend in with the season's legitimate mail and phone traffic. Here are the three scripts that dominate the season, and the defenses that work against all three.
Script 1: 'Your plan is expiring — give me your Medicare number to switch you'
The caller claims your current plan is ending and offers to move you to a better one. The red flag is the ask: Medicare does not cold-call to switch plans, and no legitimate plan counselor asks for your Medicare number on an inbound call. Never give the number to someone who called you — no matter how accurate their story sounds.
Script 2: 'Free genetic test / free brace — we just need your Medicare ID for billing'
The caller offers something free — a genetic screening, a back brace, a medical device — and asks for your Medicare ID to bill shipping or processing. Unsolicited medical offers that ask for an ID are the scam, not the gift. Medical-equipment robocalls are a long-standing enforcement target for exactly this reason.
Script 3: 'Your new card needs activation — or a refund is pending'
The caller says a new Medicare card requires activation, or that a refund is waiting on an account verification. Neither exists. Medicare cards do not need activation, and Medicare does not call about refunds. Hang up before the verification questions start.
What to do instead — every time
- Do not confirm your name, Medicare number, or address to an unknown caller.
- Let unknown calls be screened — ask who is calling and why before the phone rings. FilterMyCalls does this automatically and shows you the answer.
- Hang up and call the organization directly: Medicare at 1-800-MEDICARE (1-800-633-4227), or your plan at the number printed on your card.
- If a 'relative' calls with an urgent medical bill, use your family safe word and call them back on a known number.
Where to report
Report the attempt — even if you did not lose money — at reportfraud.ftc.gov and to Medicare at 1-800-MEDICARE. Your state's SHIP counseling program (shiphelp.org) and the Senior Medicare Patrol (smpresource.org) also take fraud reports and run free local education. Reporting is what builds enforcement cases; every report counts even when the individual loss is zero. No system catches every unwanted call, but reports shrink the haystack for everyone.
For caregivers
If you help manage a parent's or relative's phone, Open Enrollment is the moment to install a screening layer, rehearse the safe word, and agree that no plan changes happen over an inbound call. Then the season's mail and official calls can do their job — and the scam scripts end up talking to a machine.
Common Questions
Does Medicare ever call to ask for my Medicare number?
No. Medicare does not cold-call to switch plans, activate cards, or issue refunds. Never give your Medicare number to a caller who contacted you first. Hang up and call 1-800-MEDICARE (1-800-633-4227) or the number on your card.
What are the most common Medicare Open Enrollment scam calls?
Three scripts dominate: (1) your plan is expiring and the caller needs your Medicare number to switch you; (2) a free genetic test or brace requiring your Medicare ID 'for billing'; (3) a new card that needs activation or a pending refund. All three end with an information or payment ask — that is the tell.
Should I report a Medicare scam call even if I did not lose money?
Yes. Reports at reportfraud.ftc.gov and 1-800-MEDICARE give enforcement agencies the volume data and call patterns they need to build cases. Your state SHIP office and Senior Medicare Patrol (smpresource.org) also take reports.
How can I protect a parent during Medicare Open Enrollment?
Set up call screening on their phone, agree on a family safe word for any urgent money request, and make one rule together: plan changes only happen through calls they place themselves to 1-800-MEDICARE or the number on their card.
Official sources
Keep reading
1,000 real search questions about spam calls, scams, and call screening — answered directly with the full guide behind each.
Five years of enforcement against illegal calls — the mandates, the sweeps, the AI-voice ruling — and what the record means for households.
STIR/SHAKEN, carrier apps, smartphone built-ins, and third-party tools compared — what each layer catches and the gaps in every one.
Five layers — screening, callbacks, safe words, payment rules, reporting — that get most households to quiet.
Ready to screen unknown calls?
FilterMyCalls is a call-screening service for the U.S. and Canada. Know who is calling and why before you answer — about US$8/month or US$80/year, with Canadian pricing shown in CAD before purchase. Backed by our 30-day money-back guarantee — refund details for every purchase channel are in our Terms.
Questions? Email support@filtermycalls.com or visit Contact support · Privacy Policy